Philosophy Kant Reviews David Bradshaw on Kant's view of Religious Experience In the recent volume on Kant’s views about God and religion edited by Nathan Jacobs et al., David Bradshaw discusses Kant’s claim that there can be no direct experience of God. In this
Culture Reflections on Norm MacDonald ![header](http://www.keithbuhler.com/images/norm.png) I just read Norm MacDonald's "Based on a True Story", after receiving it for Christmas (Good Christmas gift!) While I can't publicly recommend it because of the seedy and lewd content (drug
Classical education Restoring the Liberal Arts -- Part I For the past twenty years or so, I’ve been trying to understand this concept of “Liberal Arts.” I don’t think I fully understand it yet. And I don’t think you do either. One
Philosophy 16 Year Olds Agree -- Philosophy is Practical Overheard last week: A 16 year old said to her peers, “So, we all agree – metaphysics is practical. Does anyone disagree? No? Let’s move on to the next question.” Wow. A bit
Life coaching Decluttering One of the most painful things we can do in life is sort through past emotions. Big emotions do not “go away” with time. They only go away with attention. They have a
Culture Trump's real genius and real danger lies in one and the same habit I read hundreds of anti-Trump articles during the primaries and the election season two years ago. Very few, almost none, of them, “got” the real problem with Trump. They said things like “he
Culture Chris Pratt, actor, troll, and preacher. Chris Pratt just received a generation achievement award from MTV so he decided to preach a sermon. It’s not really a sermon because he had to make it funny, too. He went all
Philosophy Rejoice! My own idea, for what it is worth, is that all sadness which is not either arising from the repentance of a concrete sin and hastening towards concrete amendment or restitution, or else
Politics Oh look, another article criticizing Jordan Peterson I recently stumbled across a Facebook group compiling Jordan Peterson “character assassinations”. It requires some scrolling to read all the articles, so I decided to put all the links into a single list.
Politics Whom Should Hollywood "Include"? This Wrap article laments the lack of ‘inclusion’ of LGBT characters in mainstream media films. By ‘inclusion’ of course they mean ‘exclusion.’ For including abnormality and immorality means excluding a certain kind of
Culture Where Tolkien got the Hobbit Names I just finished “reading” (i.e., listening to the audio books of) a few Dostoevsky novels and stories, hence my reading queue had an opening. I decided to finally return to the Prose Edda,
Classical education How Gordon Pennington, Businessman and Marketing Director, Discovered Classical Education
Culture Congrats to Lomachenko, three-division world champion There was a big fight tonight… Congratulations are in order to Ukraine and to its champion boxer, Lomachenko. Enjoy the highlights at CBS. It was a beautiful fight. English has its Alexander Pope,
Politics Jordan Peterson and Ben Shapiro Interview This is perhaps best single Peterson interview so far. In it, Peterson develops a host of related big claims. He states and concisely explains no less than the following: an account of the
Misc Death Reflections on my father's passing 6 years ago today my father passed away. Six years ago today, I sat holding his hand, still warm, trying to comprehend that he was dead. I arrived at the hospital a little
Classical education A corrupt teacher's union... and only the beginning It’s horrifying to hear Dr. David Perry, the President of the Hamilton Township Education Association, say this: “I’m not here to hurt anybody. I’m here to defend. No matter the worst teachers in
Classical education Politics Thomas Sowell on Three Kinds of Discrimination (on the Rubin Report) This interview is edifying, informative, and challenging on multiple levels. Dave Rubin talks with Thomas Sowell about his life, his education, and his new book on three different kinds of discrimination. It includes
Emotions Healing Trauma Emotional trauma healing resources A little while ago, I asked friends for books other resources about the connection between trauma and muscle pain. Here’s what you came up with! I added links to each title, and a
Misc Never take religious freedom for granted An email from a former student that illustrates the importance of ongoing gratitude for basic goods. It’s especially important around Easter time, for those of us who are still high on Easter joy.
Classical education John Milton on Liberal Arts Dr. Andrew Selby has been lecturing the Trinity Classical Academy staff this past academic year on the “Art of Grammar.” The art of grammar, in contrast to the mere subject, is a skill
Culture Google Dosteyevsky Predicts the Internet I am reading Dostoevsky’s Demons presently and stumbled across this description of a proto-Google, or proto-internet of information. Dostoevsky’s idea comes from the character Lizaveta. She imagines a book or series that condenses
Culture Jordan peterson Does Peterson Really Believe This Stuff? Scott Alexander at Slate Stare Codex writes a thorough review of Jordan Peterson’s book and of Peterson’s whole approach to life. While I don’t agree with the whole review, it’s worth reading. [Also:
Culture Looking for the Real Jesus... with Science? The National Geographic recently put out a piece about searching for the real Jesus. Check out Bruce Seraphim Foltz’s take down. The fallacy of “begging the question” refers to assuming that you are
Humor Smiles Misc Stacks of Papers, arranged by Category I have a neat system for organizing papers on my desk which demand attention. There are approximately eleven categories. Need to grade Begun grading, need to finish Completely graded, need to input grades
Philosophy A brief discussion of "telos" from my dissertation The question of “teleology” is the question of end-directed behavior. Does nature pursue ends? Is nature fundamentally directionless? Is the appearance of direction supervenient upon mechanical laws and random chance? In the second
Culture Reflections on the Book of Job Check out Dan Sheffler’s deep thoughts on one of the Holy Bible’s deepest* books: Job. Dr. Sheffler maintains that the book is not about evil but about suffering. In this light, he offers
Culture Seeing Other as Self, Seeing Self as Other One of the great blessings of travel is being able not only to see another culture, but returning to your own culture and seeing yourself with fresh eyes. Mirrors can’t do that. That’s
Politics Introducing Jordan Peterson If you’re just hearing about JBP, don’t let anyone define him into a box for you, too quickly. Get to know him. His critics like to use their one (and only?) trusty tool
Politics A Jordan Peterson Round Up The interview between Jordan Peterson and Cathy Newman of Channel 4 is a must see. If you have 30 minutes to spare… the video will edify and/or decimate you. A Canadian psychologist spent
Culture The Last Jedi Had to be Surprising... and it Succeeded Part 1. (No Spoilers) I don’t envy Chris Terrio. What in the world is Episode IX going to be about? Chris Terrio and JJ Abrams have to write a chapter to follow the
Empathy Charles Williams on Empathy Charles Williams, close friend of (and influence on) CS Lewis once said: “If a man seems to himself to endure the horrors of shipwreck, though he walks on dry land and breathes clear
The Super Duper Meta-Irony of the Room Once upon a time, Tommy Wiseau created a film: The Room. The Room is so bad that it’s almost miraculous. The Room is like a horrifying mixture of castle-in-a-cloud idealism and an actual
Classical education Lou markos Cs lewis Real virtue wins out every time I’m happy to announce a new interview with a classical educator, Dr. “Lou” Markos. Dr. Markos is a literature professor and authority on C.S. Lewis as well as a dynamic voice in the
Video games Monkey island Culture Monkey Island Updates Approximately 27 years ago, I played a game called “The Secret of Monkey Island” with my brothers and sisters. I was eight years old. The game was funny, fun, and an enduring source
Advice to Christian Philosophers -- Eric Silverman Interview I’m happy to announce a new interview on my other blog, Advice to Christian Philosophers.com Our 4th interview is with Eric J. Silverman, associate professor of philosophy and religious studies at Christopher Newport University.
The Alcuin Retreat (Updated) Fun update: I went to New York a couple of weeks ago for the Alcuin Retreat. Alcuin is a retreat for teachers and administrators at classical schools. The Society of Classical Learning puts
The Complete Works of C. S. Lewis The list below supplies, in chronological order, all of C. S. Lewis’s books. The reason for composing it is that many Lewis fans want to read “everything he wrote” but may have a
Upcoming Lecture at University of St. Katherine Join me at the University of St. Katherine on Monday, 7:30pm, where I’ll be speaking to the students about classical education as a form of initiation into a life of virtue and the
Prayer Roger scruton God Scruton on "Intransitive" Prayer Two years ago, I attended the “Special Divine Action” conference at Oxford University. One of the most powerful presentations was that by Roger Scruton on “intransitive prayer” – that is, prayer without an
The AFI Top 100 Movie List I am almost done watching all 100 of the American Film Institute’s best American films. “Why would you watch 100 movies?” you say… “Why would you use this list?” I’m glad you asked.
The Music of Lomanchenko After the Mayweather/McGregor fight, I’ve become mildly interested in boxing and MMA. This amounts to reading a bit about the sports, and watching a few historic fights such as Foreman’s comeback win at
Classical Education News Weekly Round-Up New classical schools are opening across the country every year. Public charter, private, and home-school cooperatives are all successfully adopting the classical model and putting it to good use. This week, Current reports
My Prediction -- Mayweather will win in round 12 Who will win on Saturday in the McGregor vs. Mayweather fight? Mayweather will win… But it will be interesting. And that’s the point. Here’s my prediction of what happens, and an explanation of
Academia Relativism A Dialog on Diversity of Opinion ONCE UPON A TIME… A professor and his star student chatted after class in the hallway. Professor A had just held forth, in his philosophy class, about the virtues of viewpoint diversity. Professor
Conservatism Politics Academia Diversity Problems, Damore Solutions As an orthodox Christian, I am ipso facto an academic heretic. It’s not just that I un-ironically defend certain religious dogmas as literally true and objectively accurate, nor even that I pray to
Student papers Guest post 2 -- "Can CEO Pay Be Unjustifiably High?" by Stephanie Obieroma This month I am happy to announce that I will be publishing a series of guest posts from my former students. I asked these students if I could publish their essays because I
Student papers Guest Post 1 "Can CEO Pay Be Unjustifiably High?" by Frances Roorda This month I am happy to announce that I will be publishing a series of guest posts from my former students. I asked these students if I could publish their essays because I
Film A New Documentary about the Religiously Unaffiliated Disclosure: I worked as a production assistant on this film. Check out this new documentary by Nathan Jacobs, titled Becoming Truly Human. It will hit your interest on multiple levels – if you
Shoes Feminism A Joyless Shoe Ad Apparently I missed this the first time around: As an ad, it works. It’s fine. Nice shoes for modern, pretty women. I get it. As a piece of art, it is wrong on
Classical education The future of classical education is higher education PITTSBURGH – June 24, 2017. Scroll down for an interview with Douglas Wilson about the future of classical education. It was filmed at the Association of Classical Christian Schools national conference, “Repairing the
Politics Culture Trump Traditional, Conservative, Comedy John Nolte over at Daily Wire provides a comedy lover’s analysis of where all the good comedies have gone. Nolte mixes two of my loves: comedy and politics. The results are insightful (if
Classical education Language, Beauty, and Standardized Tests at "Repairing the Ruins" 2017 In June 22-23, The Buhler Report attended and live-blogged several talks and workshops from the Repairing the Ruins Conference in Pittsburgh, PA. “Repairing the Ruins” is put on by the ACCS and is
Star wars Hamill Doesn't Hate Episode Eight Gizmodo reports that Mark Hamill doesn’t actually hate Episode VIII: The Last Jedi. In May, Hamill expressed his vehement disagreement with the creative decisions of Rian Johnson like this: I at one point
Movies Film Ghostbusters Wonder woman Maybe Ghostbusters (2016) Just Wasn't That Good Wait, if the Ghostbusters backlash was because America/the World doesn’t want female leads, then why is Wonder Woman 3/5ths of the way to a billion dollars? (And what’s up with Force Awakens and
Classical education Founders Academy (Texas) receives award from Hillsdale College SAT PR News reports that Founders Classical Academy in Leander, Texas will receive $25,000 from Hillsdale College as recognition of its “excellence in teaching.” Hillsdale gives out the Henry Salvatori Prize for Excellence
Jordan peterson College How can we make good use of 4 years in a university? Questioner: How can we make good use of 4 years in a university? Jordan Peterson: “Read great books! Seriously! You’ve got this four-year period that’s been carved out of your lives… You’ve got
Fairy tales Story Film Movies Why They Keep Re-Making Classic Fairy Tales You know all those new fairy remakes or satires that keep coming out? From Wicked, to Malevolent, to Shrek, etc. etc? They all have a unifying premise. Let me break it down it
Trump Media bias How Will Trump's Saudi Arabia Trip be Spun? Listening to Trump’s speech in Saudi Arabia, and watching all the pomp and circumstance… It’s all very interesting. First, it makes me glad I’m not a politician. I’m too ADD to sit through
Culture Malick Reflections on Malick's *Knight of Cups* The Knight of Cups is, I daresay, a great and beautiful film. Merely watching it challenges me the way that “conversing” with Socrates challenges. The content is not family friendly, so review the
Culture Disney Digital media Pirates Pirate Disney's Pirates Deadline reports that some hackers stole a digital copy of the new Disney movie and are planning to release it bit by bit unless Disney pays a ransom. The coercion comes from Disney’s
Philosophy Teaching Student Feedback Highlights Spring of 2017 is my last semester teaching philosophy at the University of Kentucky and Asbury University. Next fall, I’ll be teaching history, theology, writing, and ancient Greek at a secondary school. I
Relationships Parenting Culture Children Understand Everything In his novel The Idiot, Dostoevsky’s innocent Prince Mushkin explains how much children understand: “One can tell a child everything, anything. I have often been struck by the fact that parents know their
Life updates Buhlers Keith Got a Job in CA I am happy to report that God has answered with a full-time job at Trinity Classical Academy in Valencia (just north of LA). In the fall, I’ll be teaching some fun subjects like
Jordan Peterson Quotes title: Life is Suffering – and Other Jordan Peterson Quotes categories: [Philosophy] header: image: http://www.keithbuhler.com/images/banner-buhler-report.svg permalink: layout: post tags: [] comments: true author_profile: false share: true excerpt_separator: related: true Full Website Life is
Petitio or Non-Sequitur I’d like to write a philosophy book one day trying to show that a very tiny minority of arguments validly derive their conclusion from true premises. Working title: Petitio or Non-Sequitur. The thesis
Dissertation Reflections As some of you know, I recently completed my dissertation. It took me four and a half years from admission to completion, though I will formally graduate this May. This was, apparently, a
Overton window Epistemology Weird views Case-by-Case Consideration of Weird Views Some of my students have “crazy” views. Then again, I have some crazy views. The question is, is it possible to dismiss all strange, unusual, “extreme” or weird views at once? Or must
Economics Money Raise Minimum Wage, Raise Unemployment Question – Why is it that, according to Harvard Business School, minimum wage hikes don’t hurt 5-star restaurants but do shut down restaurants that employ and serve low-income Americans? Answer – basic economics.
Fathers Babies How Fathers Feel about Their Babies My best friend and his wife are having their first baby next month. We talked about how he doesn’t feel anything about “being a father” yet. I felt the same absence of feeling.
Learning styles There is One Learning Style Classical teachers are wealthy with wisdom. This embarrassment of riches allows us to be a bit shrewd about fads. While we hate to say “I told you so,” it is hard to avoid
Deification Theology Transhumanism A recent chapter on Deification David Litwa provides a fascinating (and to my mind accurate) survey of deification. His article clarifies what the notion of “becoming god” amounts to, and explains the various species of deifiction: political deification,
Berkeley Sjws Progressivism Cultural marxism Self-loathing poster child displays self-loathing posters It was a only a few weeks ago that UC Berkeley descended into a riotous hotbed of anarchy. Leftists at Berkeley repressed free speech, vandalized public property, and assaulted innocents. (Meanwhile, where outright
Books You can't learn everything in books Brendan: “You can’t learn everything in books.” Aidan: “I think I read that once.” A friend recommended I watch the Secret of Kells. It was an illuminating experience, so I pass the recommendation
Human rights Alasdair macintyre MacIntyre's Criticism of "Human Rights" Talk I was talking with a friend about Nicholas Wolterstorff’s contemporary classic Justice: Rights and Wrongs, especially Wolterstorff’s argument that only Christian moral philosophy can give a proper grounding to human rights. As I
Essay Fear of death Politics When the Fear of Death is Politicized The fear of death is a real, abiding motive. Once you realize that you are mortal, nothing will ever be the same; you can settle upon a strategy or mindset toward death or
Economics Money Sowell explains why ObamaCare failed / Thomas Sowell on the difference between Price and Cost “Prices not only help determine which particular things are produced, they are also one of the ways of rationing the inherent scarcity of
Classical education Philosophy History Is 'History' a separate subject? Should history be a taught as a separate subject (in middle and high school)? It seems pretty obvious to most people that the answer is ‘Yes.’ They think that history should be taught
Facebook Divorcing Facebook Considering getting off Facebook? Ever feel that Facebook has negative effects on your life? Check out Audrey Wagner’s excellent new book. I read her book and found it enjoyable and illuminating. She comes
Humor Socrates Socrates is God's Gift to Athens (or a Troll) / Socrates was put on trial 2,400 years ago, but he is as relevant as ever. Plato was right to call him “Socrates become beautiful and new” (Second Letter). One of the ways
Money Stipends Philosophy Academia Reflections on Philosophy Department Graduate Stipends Now that I am a postdoc scholar at the University of Kentucky (Go ‘Cats!), I am reflecting back on my experience as a Teaching Assistant. Stipend amounts are hard to find One thing
Saint constantine school Classical education Academia King's College Announces Partnership with New Saint Constantine School John Mark Reynolds, the founder of the Torrey Honors Institute (my alma mater), started a new school: the Saint Constantine School. Rather than start small, Saint Constantine has partnered for college credit with
Workflow Dissertations Writing How Big is a Dissertation? My philosophy dissertation was about 200 pages. Everyone knows that each discipline has different standards. History dissertations tend to be longer, and science dissertations tend to be shorter. The question is, how different?
Film Movies Christianity A Sequel to "The Passion of the Christ -- Resurrection Randall Wallace is writing a sequel to The Passion. It will be called “The Resurrection.” Gibson anticipates it to be “three years off.” (In an earlier article, Mark Joseph explains why “faith-based” film
Humor Ann coulter This week in hypocrisy A: “The thing I hate about some of these online pundits is that they are so crass, uncouth, low rent, vulgar, uncivilized, and rude. They are so hateful and irrational, they’ll call anyone
Star wars Abrams Admits that the Rey/Princess Leia Hug Was a Mistake When Han Solo meets his fate in Star Wars: The Force Awakens, fans and characters alike screamed in grief. Some people were more disturbed by a scene that comes shortly after, when Rey
Logic Peter Geach says logic is not partisan “To me it appears blasphemous to say God is ‘above’ logic. Logic is not partisan, and knows nothing but to strike straight; but the sword is invincible, bearing the Maker’s name.” –Peter Geach
Star wars Humor Ridiculous Star Wars Things From its inception, the Star Wars Universe has been a mythopoeic cathedral for the imagination exploring the universal archetypes of good and evil, fatherhood and childhood, war and peace – and also a
Classical education Philosophy Thomas Aquinas College's Proposal for Liberal Education Thomas Aquinas College is especially dear to my heart for two reasons: it was the school from which I learned about Great Books education and it was the first college I was admitted
Philosophy Politics Trump Abductive reasoning Is Trump’s Claim About “millions” Of Voters An Unconfirmed Hypothesis Or Provable Falsehood? A few weeks ago, Donald Trump tweeted that he would have won the popular vote if not for “millions” of votes from illegal immigrants. In addition to winning the Electoral College in a
Movies Film 10 Reasons to See Bells of St Mary's We just watched the Bing Crosby/ Ingmar Bergman classic Bells of St. Mary’s. Here are 10 reasons to watch it. If you like Bing Crosby, watch Bells of St. Mary’s. If you want
Trump Politics Resisting the results of this election is a threat to our Democracy Donald Trump refused to say that he’d respect the results of this election.That’s a direct threat to our democracy.— Hillary Clinton (@HillaryClinton) October 24, 2016 Threat to our Democracy Groups like #DisruptJ20 and
Torrey honors Classical education Check out the Torrey Honors Institute before the deadline My Alma Mater, Biola University, is still one of the best places to learn. College-bound students can still apply to the Torrey Honors Institute by January 15.
Isis Al-Quaeda Calls ISIS Extreme It begins. Radical Islam is a splinter from Islam more generally. But even Radical Islam will splinter and rival with each other.
Politics Conservatism NY Times hiring faith reporter Jan 12, 2017 The New York Times has the dubious distinction of being one of the most Pulitzer-winning, widely-circulated, widely-read news organizations in the country that least understands the Red State mind. They
Philosophy Philosophy of Forgiveness Of potential interest to philosophers working in virtue ethics, philosophy of religion, or ethics: A CFP on forgiveness.
Politics Feminism Paglia Tells Madonna to Age Gracefully Jaw drop. Camille Paglia deconstructs the (60 year old) Madonna by defending the (younger) Madonna’s attitude and criticizing the (older) Madonna’s gracelessness. The main problem facing today’s aging women is not sexism but
Politics Facebook Conservatism Liberal privilege Facebook Hires Quasi-Conservative, HuffPo Freaks Out Media companies like Facebook, Google, and Twitter are realizing their Silicon Valley left-leaning liberal privilege. While Twitter is doubling-down, Facebook and Google at least are trying to strike a new balance. General rule
Joe Klein calls Trump "news manipulator in chief" This week’s Joe Klein Time Magazine article argues that Russian meddling in the U.S. was a bigger story than Trump’s vile comments about groping groupies but that the media gave the latter more
Politics Trump Trump tells DHS to get ready to build the wall Trump is preparing to build the wall. Zero Hedge and Reuters report that his administration asked the DHS for an assessment of “all assets available for border wall and barrier construction.” The report
Workflow Reading Take the Reading Survey One of my new year’s resolutions is to publish a book about – well, about reading books. I can use your help! This reading survey asks you about your reading habits. The results